4.8 • +11k Ratings
Save
Print
Edit
How did the English get caught up in a civil war that resulted in the killing of their king and the abolishment of the monarchy from 1649 to 1660? The English Civil War was a struggle between King Charles I and Parliament over government control. Charles I wished to rule alone without interference from Parliament, but Parliament viewed this kind of self-rule as abusive to their rights and liberties. Religion also played a significant role. But what caused the revolt that ended with the king's execution and a commonwealth government?
King Charles I (r. 1625-1649) believed that a king was divinely appointed by God and should rule his kingdom absolutely–which is a type of government defined as absolutism. However, since the Magna Carta, the English believed the people had rights to their person and property above the rule of any king–this is what we call constitutionalism. This difference in opinion resulted in tensions between the King and Parliament, and Charles refused to call any more parliaments after 1629. He was determined to rule on his own and did until 1637.
Charles wanted to bring religious uniformity to his three kingdoms of England, Scotland, and Ireland. However, he chose the Church of England as his model. As a result, the Scots revolted when he tried to force a new prayer book on Scotland in 1637. Many English also opposed Charles' religious reform because they thought it resembled Catholicism, which they hated and feared.
When Charles finally turned to Parliament in 1640 for military funds, they responded that the threat to their liberties was more pressing than the Scottish revolt. In retaliation, he tried to have five leading members of Parliament arrested but failed. Finally, in 1642, Charles left London to raise an army to fight Parliament, and Parliament created their own New Model Army. Civil war erupted.
Absolutism is a government structure where the monarch argues that their right to rule comes from God because he is God's appointee on earth. Therefore, the monarch is above any other law because of this divine connection.
On the other hand, constitutionalism limits the government through a written set of laws or constitutions. Enacted in 1215 and reconfirmed numerous times until the Tudor era ended, the Magna Carta was considered a constitution. After the English Civil War, Parliament used the Magna Carta to establish a constitutionalist government.
There were many potential causes for the outbreak of civil war, and historians have debated these causes since the war ended. Three prominent schools of history surrounding this topic include the Marxists, the Revisionists, and the Post-Revisionists.
The Marxists, chief among them Christopher Hill, believed that the English Civil War was a class struggle between the elite nobility and a rising lower class. He championed Oliver Cromwell as a revolutionary hero against a despotic King Charles I. Other Marxists believed that strained economic circumstances due to England's role in the Thirty Years War.
The revisionists are less united than the Marxists, but they all agree that the English Civil War was not part of a steady march towards progress. For example, Conrad Russell, a prominent revisionist, believed that the Civil War's causes were not in England alone but also in Scotland and Ireland. According to Russell, Charles tried to govern his three kingdoms as a single body, but they differed in politics and religion, so everything fell into chaos.
Post-Revisionism is another school without much agreement but primarily challenges the reliance of "great men" to tell the story of the Civil War's causes. Post-Revisionists like Ann Hughes incorporate new ways of looking at the conflict, for example, through gender studies. She argued that the Civil War had no long-term causes but instead resulted from "conflicting views of religion, politics, and culture." 1 She states that the common people had just as much impact on events as the elites.
Royalist Win | Parliament Win |
Battle of Braddock Down, January 19, 1643. Secured the northern county of Cornwall for King Charles. | Battle of Newbury, September 20, 1643. Charles withdrew, leaving the almost conquered New Model Army with the win. The beginning of Charles' decline. |
Battle of Stratton, May 16, 1643. Major Royalist victory that resulted in 1700 captured Parliamentarians. | Battle of Marsten Moor, July 2, 1644. Oliver Cromwell secures victory and becomes a war hero. |
Storming of Bristol, July 26, 1643. Royalists capture the strategically important town of Bristol. | Battle of Naseby, June 14, 1645. Royalist forces were destroyed, and Parliament's war victory was assured. |
Charles surrendered to the Scottish army in 1646 and tried to convince them to fight against the Parliamentarians. However, the Scottish ransomed the king to Parliament in January 1647. Meanwhile, petitions from the New Model Army to Parliament for back pay resulted in the petitioners' arrest and orders to disband. In response, the army organized against Parliament and seized the king in June 1647. Army generals such as Oliver Cromwell took over control of Parliament.
Oliver Cromwell (1599-1658)
Oliver Cromwell was a member of Parliament and a general in the New Model Army. He was staunchly Puritan (a religious sect that did not conform to the Church of England) and believed God directed his actions in war and statecraft. His charisma and military effectiveness made him a powerful political player on behalf of the New Model Army. His ability to inspire and direct the populace led to his nomination as Lord Protector of the new Commonwealth of England, which he accepted in 1653.
Charles refused all attempts to negotiate a settlement between the Royalists and Parliamentarians. Finally, in 1649, the Army-controlled Parliament under Cromwell put Charles I on trial for high treason. The king was executed on January 30, 1649.
The Commonwealth fell apart after Cromwell died in 1658. Parliament then invited Charles II to return to England as king in 1660, marking the Restoration period. However, when Charles II died in 1685, his Catholic brother, James II, became king. Catholic fear combined with James' desire to rule in a more absolutist fashion brought memories of the Civil War back to the surface. This unrest led to the Glorious Revolution in 1688, which replaced James II with his daughter and son-in-law, Mary II and William III, under a constitutional monarchy.
References
1. Ann Hughes, Causes of the English Civil War, 1991
The English Civil War was a fight for government control between King Charles I and Parliament. It resulted in the execution of the king, the exile of his son and heir, and the establishment of a commonwealth government that lasted 11 years.
There are multiple causes for the English Civil War, and historians have hotly debated the subject. Some causes include:
There are multiple causes for the English Civil War, and historians have hotly debated the subject. Some causes include:
The Civil War began when King Charles I and the British Parliament divided over Charles' attempts to rule by himself without Parliament and standardize religious practices across England, Scotland, and Ireland.
The English Civil War ended after Parliament executed King Charles I and set up a new commonwealth government under Lord Protector Oliver Cromwell.
Be perfectly prepared on time with an individual plan.
Test your knowledge with gamified quizzes.
Create and find flashcards in record time.
Create beautiful notes faster than ever before.
Have all your study materials in one place.
Upload unlimited documents and save them online.
Identify your study strength and weaknesses.
Set individual study goals and earn points reaching them.
Stop procrastinating with our study reminders.
Earn points, unlock badges and level up while studying.
Create flashcards in notes completely automatically.
Create the most beautiful study materials using our templates.
Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.
