StudySmarter - The all-in-one study app.
4.8 • +11k Ratings
More than 3 Million Downloads
Free
‘Little Hans’ is a pseudonym for Herbert Graf, the son of the critic musician Max Graf, a follower of Freud’s theories. Little Hans was born in 1903 in Vienna. Freud did not directly treat him but rather through his father, who would correspond with Freud through letters, explaining and questioning the son’s behaviour and conversations. It wasn’t till Little Hans was around five years old that Freud interacted with him directly.
The Little Hans case study (1909) is one of Freud’s most famous case studies. The case of Little Hans is about the fears and traumas of a five-year-old boy. Hans’ father requested Freud’s support for dealing with the boy’s fear of horses.
Little Hans feared horses, Flaticon
Freud demonstrated interest in the role of sexual drives concerned children’s development. He focused on Little Han’s psychosexual development to resolve the mystery about Hans’ fear of horses.
He realised that Little Hans was going through the phallic stage of the Oedipus complex, which means he feared castration.
From the age of three, his parents reported little Hans showing interest in ‘widdlers’, which referred to his penis and that of other males, including animals. His mother threatened to call the doctor and get him castrated unless he stopped playing with it.
When Little Hans was four years old, he went through a traumatic event.
He witnessed an accident with a heavily loaded horse that collapsed in front of him. After the accident, his parents noticed that he became afraid of horses, especially those carrying a heavy load and those with darker circles around the eyes or wearing blinkers.
He feared seeing other horses, and he didn’t want to leave home for the phobia of horses.
Freud presumed that his focus on male genitals was connected to this fear of horses and Little Hans’ mother eventually threatened her son with calling a doctor to get him castrated if he did not stop this obsession.
Hans was traumatised with the view of the horse’s large genitalia, which led Little Hans to avoid leaving his home because he did not want to encounter any horses.
The father reported it to Freud, describing the worry about male genitals. Little Hans’ father, Max Graf, shared with Freud several conversations with his son.
One specific conversation between Little Hans and his father revolved around a dream or fantasy he had had, in which he described two giraffes entering a room.
One was crumpled whilst the other one was big, and Little Hans took the crumpled one away, which caused the big one to call out for it.
Hans described his dream to his father:
In the night there was a big giraffe in the room, and a crumpled one: and the big one called out because I took the crumpled one away from it. Then it stopped calling out: and I sat down on top of the crumpled one.
This was interpreted as a morning routine involving Little Hans and his father and mother waking up (the father is the big giraffe and the crumpled one was the mother). Freud and the father also suggested that the giraffe’s neck could also be interpreted as a phallic symbol, but Hand did not truly entertain and dismiss this.
When Hans was three and a half years old, his mother gave birth to his younger sister. Hans began competing for his mother’s attention and showing signs of jealousy. He stated that he wished his mother would drown his younger sister in the bath. However, Hans also developed a fear of drowning.
The baby sister’s birth led Little Hans to question the process around conception and childbirth. The parents answered, telling Hans that a stork bird delivers babies in bags.
Considering Freud did not personally interact with Little Hans until he was five years old, we have to consider the following interpretations with that in mind. Most of Freud’s theories about Little Hans’ fear and trauma revolve around correspondences with Little Hans’ father.
The Oedipus Complex is one of Freud’s most infamous conceptualised theories, which he suggests to be a crucial stage in child development.
The Oedipus Complex, curated by Sigmund Freud, is a psychoanalytic theory revolving around the idea of a sexual desire for the parent, which is the opposite sex to the child, and insists that a natural rivalry with the same-sex parent develops to win the attention of the opposite sex parent
Freud described Little Hans’ interest in ‘widdlers’ as unconscious motives. He also added that Hans had experienced repression through his mother’s threats, which developed into his fear of castration.
Freud thought Hans was jealous of his sister because it reminded him of his pleasure during the earlier stages of development. He wanted his sister to drown in the bath so he could have his mother to himself.
When Little Hans wanted his father to go away and be alone with his mother, Freud explained that Hans desires his mother and related this to the Oedipus complex. According to Freud, Hans wanted a large penis to compete with his father and marry his mother, as he had entered the phallic stage of development.
Freud also associated Hans’ fear of white horses as part of the Oedipus Complex, as the horses represented his father and the fear that he could bite him. Freud interpreted this as Hans’ fear that his father would castrate him as a punishment for his incestuous desire for his mother. This was associated with a defence mechanism known as identification with the aggressor.
By adopting the father’s mannerisms, a child’s identification with the aggressor reduces the chances of conflicts occurring as they appease the father figure.
The fear started as an Oedipal conflict and developed due to the mother allowing Hans in the parents’ bed and his father opposing him getting into bed with them.
We need to consider the strengths and weaknesses of the case study to analyse the legitimacy of Freud’s claims.
The case study suffers from the following weaknesses.
The studies were based on one child, and for this reason, they may not be generalised or applicable to others. Little Hans had specific experiences, so whilst the case study revolves around him and is specifically relevant to him, the interpretations can only be related to him as well. It is a lack of population validity.
The case study requires a subjective interpretation, and it could vary from analyst to analyst. Hans’ phobia could be seen differently by others, which means that the study case is unreliable. However, Freud collected very detailed data from Hans and his parents. Because of the rich data collection, the study can be re-analysed on an interpretative level relating specifically to Hans.
Jerome Wakefield (2007) used Bowlby’s attachment theory to Little Hans’ giraffe experience. The outcome was a symbolic way to compete for the mother’s attention with his toddler sister. Therefore, Bowlby’s findings rejected Freud’s conclusion linking it to the Oedipus complex.
It’s known that Little Hans’ parents were Freud’s followers, and the information provided to Freud may be considered biased. They may have asked Hans leading questions based on Freud’s theories and looked at Hans’ case through the lens of Freud’s interpretations. The study case is not considered scientific as the unconscious castration fears are not testable, and Freud’s Oedipus Complex cannot be measured.
As Freud was aware that Little Hans’ father followed his theories, it can be called into question the conversations between father and son, as the questions could have been leading.
Regarding ethics, Hans himself could not consent, and the father gave consent. Hans also was unable to withdraw from the study.
Let’s consider the following strengths of the case study of Little Hans.
The application of Freud’s studies and theories are focused on sexual and unconscious qualities, which has led to a new path for psychotherapy and psychoanalysis to be further studied.
The case study was initially proposed to understand and treat Hans’ fear of horses and see whether there was any support for the Oedipus complex. It also helped track the development of a child aged between four to five.
Years later, when Little Hans became an adult, he had paid a visit to Freud, who found he was a healthy man with a successful career, suggesting there was a long-term resolution.
Based on the study, applying Freud’s concept and evidence for psychosexual stages and theory of gender development revealed the unconscious drives, which resulted in Hans’ cured phobia of horses.
The Little Hans case study (1909) is one of Freud’s most famous case studies. The study is about the fears and traumas of a five-year-old boy. Hans’ father requested Freud’s support for dealing with the boy’s fear of horses.
Little Hans was going through the psychosexual conflicts a child encounters during development, precisely the phallic stage. Freud believed he was being repressed when his mother threatened him to get castrated if he kept playing with his penis. Freud explained the fear of horses as part of the Oedipus complex, and the fear of a white horse was a symbol to represent his fear of his father.
The method applied is a long term treatment or longitudinal case study. The study describes Hans’ conflicts from the age of three until five years old.
Only once, most of the study was provided by his father exchanging letters with Freud, quoting relevant conversations he had with the son.
The data provided by Hans parents started when he was three years old until he reached five. However, this information is not clear. Freud also reported encountering Little Hans at the age of nineteen.
Be perfectly prepared on time with an individual plan.
Test your knowledge with gamified quizzes.
Create and find flashcards in record time.
Create beautiful notes faster than ever before.
Have all your study materials in one place.
Upload unlimited documents and save them online.
Identify your study strength and weaknesses.
Set individual study goals and earn points reaching them.
Stop procrastinating with our study reminders.
Earn points, unlock badges and level up while studying.
Create flashcards in notes completely automatically.
Create the most beautiful study materials using our templates.
Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.